Air Fryer Grilled Cheese

Air Fryer Grilled Cheese is absolutely the best way to make these beloved sandwiches! Once you do them the your air fryer you will be hooked for life.

Pin

This air fryer grilled cheese sandwich is life changing! I kid you not. Once you try it, you will never go back to pan frying.

Grilled cheese is an easy sandwich beloved by kids and adults alike. We still love dipping a melty grilled cheese in our tomato soup! Perfect comfort food.

What you need

• bread – your favorite store bought or homemade bread. See below for suggestions.
• cheese – see below for suggestions on types of cheeses to use
• mayonnaise

Pin

Why mayonnaise instead of butter? Mayo gives your grilled cheese the most wonderful crunchy texture on the outside. It also doesn’t make the bread soggy like when you use too much butter.

Optional additions

• sliced green onion or chives
• tuna
• ham
• bacon
• jalapenos
• tomato
• caramelized onions
• avocado
• mushrooms
• pepperoni (make a pizza grilled cheese with mozzarella)

What are the best cheeses to use?

Lots of cheeses will work for grilled cheese. The thing you need to think about is that you want a hard cheese so that it doesn’t soften too much and leak out of the bread before the bread is toasted. Some great cheeses include;

• cheddar cheese – mild, medium or sharp cheddar cheese will work. Sharp cheese will take the longest to melt.
• gouda cheese
• gruyere cheese
• Swiss cheese
• sharp provolone

How to make it

1. Spread mayonnaise on one side of each piece of bread.
2. Repeat with all slices.
3. Place one slice mayonnaise side down in air fryer basket. Add cheese on dry side of bread.
4. Top with any additional toppings and the second piece of bread, with the dry side down.
5. Air fry 4-5 minutes until golden brown.
6. Flip. Air fry an additional 4-5 minutes.
7. Cheese should be melty and bread golden. Serve hot.

Pin

What types of cheeses to use?

Your choice of cheese is basically endless for delicious grilled cheese sandwiches. Pick your favorites. Mix and match several different types.

• American cheese
• cheddar (use mild for melting and a bit of sharp for flavor)
• Monterey Jack
• pepper jack
• colby
• gouda
• brie
• fontina
• Swiss
• mozzarella

Pin

Types of bread to use

Whatever type of bread you choose, get the best quality you can find. It makes all the difference.

• white sandwich bread, like this brioche
• sourdough bread
• rye
• wheat
• multigrain

Pin

Pro tips for the perfect grilled cheese

• For hard cheeses, grate cheese rather than slicing. It melts faster and more evenly.
• I like to let a bit of cheese hang off of the bread. It gets crispy, crunchy and browned.
• Know your air fryer. Air fryers cook at different wattages and therefore will be done at different rates. Closely check the sandwich the first time you make it in your air fryer to ensure it isn’t getting too brown.
• Turn sandwich half way through the cooking process for better browning.

Pin

Other delicious air fried recipes

• tortilla chips
• beet chips
• pork loin
• chicken tenders
• hot pockets

Tools I use

• air fryer
• tongs
• spatula
• cutting board

Connect with us through our social media ages! Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest, Twitter.

If you have any questions or comments, please ask in the comment section below. We’d love to hear from you!

I hope you enjoyed the recipe today!

Enjoy. And have fun cooking!

📖 Recipe

Originally published February 3, 2021.

This post may contain affiliate links, which means I get a small commission if you go to the link and purchase something at no additional cost to you. See FTC Disclosure here.